Flash's Opinion

Quote :

AND ANOTHER THING! I've seen many questionable clan ideals, and two stick out in my mind. The first is the Alchemy clan made by Pat because he has been watching FMA lately. The first paragraph of thee KKG is enough to have it denied. THEY DONT HAVE CHAKRA! Is that not a red flag? All living things have chakra, so if a person doesn't have chakra then they are either dead or weren't alive in the first place. He then goes on to describe an alternative power source called "Alchemic energy" or something like that. A source that "unlike chakra, it is not a finite resource." If it isn't a finite source of energy, that means its an.. infinite source of energy, and thus as long as he has the "resources" he can continue to use attack forever. Not only was this looked over in my opinion, but by ditching the idea of use of chakra for something completely different, it is no longer even naruto based. The foundation of naruto is the concept of chakra; take that away, and your not RPing naruto anymore. This isn't an attempt to knock Pat, im just trying to say that this is something that should be looked into. Alternative 'forms' or 'types' of chakra is cool, as long as its still chakra, but an entirely different made up thing shouldn't be approved.

You speak of creativity and anything being possible, then contradict yourself? It's true, that chakra plays a main role in Naruto, but this is a Naruto RPG. Nearly anything is possible! Leave Pat alone, because at least he does confine himself to a set of boundaries that many try to stick to when making their characters.

Flash wasn't attacking Pat. He even said he didn't mean it as a bash. Way to Phail Pendo.

Phail? Way to misspell fail, Steph. ^_^
And yeah, I know he didn't mean to attack Pat. But I'm simply saying that Pat was a bad example, considering he didn't even get all of his facts straight...

FIRST OF ALL! you wanna know where I got my facts from?! Second Sentence in his clan application it says:

Quote :

Members of this clan do not have any chakra.

Thats where I get my facts from; very straight forward.

Second of all, I dont think your getting the point. This wasn't at all meant to attack anyone, so stop thinking im trying to bully anyone and just read it for what it is. People try to use things like this to promote their own agenda. I DO speak of creativity and I DO speak of anything being possible. I believe that a version of alchemy can be replicated with the laws of the naruto verse, but there is a difference between being creative and making things up. Its not about pat, or it being OP, or even that its from another series; its that it ISN'T applicable by the rules of naruto and thus shouldn't be approved.

I believe that there is no need to replicate alchemy using the rules of the naruverse, it's fine enough as it is, and presents no practical problems whatsoever. ^.^

As for that, I meant to edit that, than forgot to. It's mentioned, if you would read further than the second sentence, that he has a small amount of chakra, if you would've just read a few more sentences on, you would've seen

" it is smaller even than that of an infant, and almost unnoticeable"